You’ve just upped your running mileage or hit a new personal best in the gym, but now your knee aches. Should you push through, or are you risking a serious setback?

Getting back into exercise is a great way to stay active, but aches and pains can sometimes leave you wondering whether you should keep going or take a break. Not every sore muscle means you have an injury, but ignoring the wrong type of pain could make a problem worse.

So, how can you tell the difference between normal post-exercise soreness and an injury?

When is pain after exercise normal?

It is common to feel some muscle soreness after trying a new activity, increasing your training or working muscles harder than usual. This is often known as delayed onset muscle soreness (DOMS).

DOMS usually develops several hours after exercise and clinically tends to peak between 24 to 72 hours. It may feel like general aching, stiffness or tenderness in the muscles you have worked. It tends to improve gradually over the following few days.

For example, you may feel stiff in your legs after returning to running or notice muscle soreness after introducing strength exercises you have not done before. This type of soreness does not necessarily mean you have injured yourself.

Signs that your pain may be an injury

Sports injuries can present differently from ordinary muscle soreness. The pain may be more focused in one particular area and can sometimes start during the activity itself rather than several hours afterwards.


These symptoms do not necessarily tell you exactly what the problem is, but they can be a reason to stop and seek appropriate advice.

Does pain mean you should stop exercising?

Not always. The answer can depend on the type and severity of the symptoms. A highly effective way to gauge this is by using the clinical "Traffic Light System" to monitor your pain on a scale of 0 to 10:

  • Green (0-3/10 - Safe): Mild discomfort that settles quickly after exercise. You can usually continue.
  • Amber (4-5/10 - Monitor): Moderate pain. Changing the intensity, duration or type of activity may be enough to prevent symptoms from becoming more troublesome.
  • Red (6+/10 - Stop): Severe pain. Trying to push through significant or worsening pain is unlikely to be helpful.

A useful approach is to pay attention to how your body responds during and after exercise. If an activity consistently causes increasing pain or leaves you struggling with normal movement afterwards, it may be worth reviewing what you are doing.

The Science of Load Management: Why sudden changes cause pain

In sports medicine, injuries often occur when the "load" placed on your tissues exceeds their current capacity to adapt. A sudden change in training can place more demand on your body than it has had time to safely process. 

This can happen when you:
  • Increase running distance quickly
  • Add extra training sessions
  • Return to sport after a long break
  • Suddenly increase weights or repetitions
  • Change your training surface or equipment
  • Start a new sport or activity 

Your muscles, tendons and joints need time to adapt to new demands. Gradually building up activity can help your body adjust rather than going from very little exercise to a high training load overnight.

What if the pain keeps coming back?

Pain that repeatedly appears during the same activity is worth paying attention to, even if it settles afterwards.

For example, you may notice knee discomfort every time you increase your running distance or shoulder pain whenever you return to swimming. Repeated symptoms could indicate that something about the activity, training routine or physical demands needs closer consideration.

Rather than simply stopping all activity indefinitely, understanding the pattern of your symptoms can help determine what needs to change.

Listen to your body without fearing every ache

Being active does not mean you need to avoid every ache or sensation. Some muscle soreness is a normal part of adapting to exercise, while certain symptoms may indicate that something needs attention.

The key is to notice changes in your symptoms, avoid repeatedly aggravating significant pain and seek advice when you are unsure. Consider getting professional advice if pain is persistent, keeps returning or is affecting the way you exercise or move. It is particularly important to seek assessment following a significant injury, especially if there is considerable swelling, weakness, instability or difficulty using the affected area.

If sports-related pain is affecting your ability to stay active or keeps returning, The Physiotherapy Centre can help assess your symptoms and guide you on the appropriate next steps. Book a comprehensive biomechanical assessment today to pinpoint the root cause of your pain and get safely back to the activities you love.

References:
  • Gabbett, T. J. (2016). The training-injury prevention paradox: should athletes be training smarter and harder? British Journal of Sports Medicine. (Explores the clinical principles of load management, tissue capacity, and how rapid spikes in training load increase injury risk).
  • Cheung, K., Hume, P., & Maxwell, L. (2003). Delayed onset muscle soreness: treatment strategies and performance factors. Sports Medicine. (Details the physiological mechanisms of DOMS and its typical 24- to 72-hour peak window).